How to Tell What the OBD2 Receives from the ECU

When using an OBD2 scanner, understanding the communication between the device and the vehicle’s Engine Control Unit (ECU) is crucial. While most vehicles respond with a single data stream, cars with multiple ECUs can send separate responses for each. This article explores how to interpret these responses and determine which data is most relevant for diagnostics.

Decoding Multiple ECU Responses

Sending a standard OBD2 command, like 01 0C (engine RPM), often results in a single response. However, in vehicles with multiple ECUs, each ECU might reply with slightly different data. For instance, a 01 00 command (supported PIDs) might yield multiple 4-byte responses, each indicating the supported parameters for that specific ECU.

One response typically shows a comprehensive set of supported PIDs (Parameter IDs), indicated by various binary flags turned on. Other responses might have fewer flags enabled, often a subset of the flags present in the most comprehensive response.

SENT: 01 00
RECEIVED: 
00 BF BF AC D3 - This response has the most binary flags turned on
00 98 18 80 11 - 8 flags on here
00 98 18 80 13 - 9 flags on here

In this example, the last two lines represent responses from secondary ECUs, with a subset of the flags activated in the first, more complete response.

Identifying the Primary ECU

While multiple ECU responses can seem confusing, it’s important to understand their significance. Using a CAN ID mask or filter allows focusing on specific ECUs. However, the question remains: is there a primary ECU that holds the most critical diagnostic information?

The answer isn’t always straightforward. While one ECU might handle core engine functions and provide the most comprehensive data set, other ECUs contribute valuable information about specific systems like transmission, ABS, or body control modules.

Currently, there isn’t a single OBD2 command to definitively identify the “most significant” ECU. Determining which ECU to prioritize depends on the diagnostic task. For general engine diagnostics, focusing on the ECU with the most comprehensive PID support (most flags enabled in the 01 00 response) is often a good starting point.

Utilizing All Available Data

Rather than solely focusing on a “primary” ECU, consider all responses as potentially valuable. Each ECU offers insights into the specific system it manages. Analyzing the combined data from all ECUs can provide a more holistic understanding of the vehicle’s overall health and performance. Advanced diagnostic tools and software can help manage and interpret these multiple data streams effectively.

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/GettyImages-1247288378-23412c823a6b4d27b6875c6b68997c5b.jpg)

Conclusion

Understanding how to interpret the data received from multiple ECUs via OBD2 is crucial for effective vehicle diagnostics. While there isn’t a universal command to pinpoint a “primary” ECU, analyzing the responses, particularly the supported PIDs, can guide diagnostic efforts. Leveraging all available ECU data offers a comprehensive view of the vehicle’s status, leading to more accurate troubleshooting and repair.