Choosing the right tool kit is essential for every homeowner and car enthusiast. Whether you’re tackling home repairs, assembling furniture, or maintaining your vehicle, having a reliable set of tools can save you time, money, and frustration. A good tool kit should be versatile, durable, and well-organized. This guide reviews some of the best tool kits available, focusing on their quality, tool selection, portability, and overall value, helping you find the best tool kit for your home and car needs.
Crescent 180-Piece Professional Tool Set: The Best Overall
The Crescent 180-Piece Professional Tool Set stands out as an excellent all-around tool kit. It’s particularly well-suited for automotive work, tractors, lawnmowers, and other motorized equipment, while also being useful for a range of household tasks. This set features high-quality sockets and ratchets that performed exceptionally well in tests. You get two robust ratchets with three extenders for accessing tight spots, and a comprehensive collection of over 80 sockets in both metric and SAE sizes, including a very useful 5/8″ spark plug socket. The set also includes 12 combination wrenches that are among the best in their category, along with reliable screwdrivers and a magnetic bit driver with 48 assorted bits. The needle-nose pliers are of high quality, offering smooth operation. However, it’s worth noting that standard pliers and tongue and groove pliers are not included in this kit. Metric and SAE hex keys are provided in convenient, sturdy holders.
While this set is not recommended as a starter kit for absolute beginners due to its focus on automotive applications, its broad tool selection makes it highly capable for many home-related projects. Adding a hammer would further enhance its versatility for home repairs. In testing, the sockets, ratchets, and wrenches were particularly impressive, while the other tools were of good, solid quality. The screwdrivers are comfortable to use in dry conditions, but the smooth handles can become slippery when oily. The carrying case effectively organizes the tools, but its durability could be improved. One test unit arrived with a gouge in the case bottom, and a socket holder was slightly deformed. For users who need a more rugged case, the DeWalt 108-Piece Mechanics Tools Kit and Socket Set might be a better option. Overall, the Crescent Tool Set is a fantastic choice for those looking for a strong starter kit for auto maintenance or a superior socket and wrench set to add to their existing tool collection.
Diverse tool selection of the Crescent tool kit, ideal for mechanics.
DeWalt 108-Piece Mechanics Tools Kit and Socket Set: Best High-Quality Socket Set
The DeWalt 108-Piece Mechanics Tools Kit and Socket Set excels in tool quality and case design. It achieved high scores across all testing metrics, just slightly behind the Black and Decker set in general use selection. The exceptional quality and functionality of the tools were immediately evident, particularly the sockets and ratchet which were easy to assemble and provided a secure fit. Testers used this kit effectively for tasks like adjusting ski bindings and bike repairs. The carrying case is lightweight, portable, and features robust metal latches. DeWalt’s reputation for durability, confirmed by long-term users, adds to the appeal of this set.
However, this tool kit has a limited tool selection, lacking the versatility needed for broader household tasks. It does not include essential tools like hammers, pliers, or tape measures. For a more versatile set, the Amazon Basics 173-Piece Hand Tool Kit is a recommended alternative. But, if you already own these basic tools or plan to acquire them separately, the DeWalt 108-piece kit is an excellent choice, particularly for users prioritizing high-quality sockets and a durable, well-organized case.
Well-organized and elegant DeWalt tool kit case.
Amazon Basics 173-Piece Hand Tool Kit: Best Value for Money
For those seeking the best bang for their buck, the Amazon Basics 173-Piece Hand Tool Kit is a standout option. This set provides a comprehensive selection of household tools at an exceptional value. It includes a small hammer, saw, various pliers, a tape measure, a selection of nails and screws, and a torpedo level. The small socket set is convenient, the snap-off blade utility knife is adequate, and the level is useful for basic tasks like hanging pictures. The screwdrivers and magnetic bit driver feature comfortable, rounded handles. The inclusion of SAE and metric hex keys is a practical addition for bike owners and general use.
However, the pliers in this set are a weak point, with small, slick grips and loose joints. The slip joint pliers were rated as the poorest in testing. For higher quality pliers, the Channellock 5-Piece Pliers Set is recommended. The ratchet in the Amazon Basics kit has widely spaced gears, making it slower to use. The carrying case also has room for improvement in tool retention. Tools can fall out when the case is opened and closed repeatedly. Despite these drawbacks, the Amazon Basics tool set offers impressive value and utility, making it an ideal starter kit for budget-conscious homeowners.
Comprehensive tool selection of the Amazon Basics tool kit for home improvement projects.
Channellock 5-Piece Pliers Set: Highest Quality Pliers
If your primary need is for high-quality pliers, the Channellock 5-Piece Pliers Set is unmatched. This set embodies the renowned quality of the Channellock brand. The tongue and groove pliers, often referred to as “channellocks,” are the best tested, offering the widest size range, essential for plumbing tasks. The slip joint pliers and diagonal cutters also ranked top, with the cutters performing cleanly on plastic and wire. The needle nose pliers have an exceptionally narrow tip for precision work in tight spaces. All pliers in the set operate smoothly with minimal play and feature long handles with vinyl sheaths for enhanced leverage.
While this set delivers exceptional plier quality and durability, it is limited to pliers only and is a premium-priced option. The investment buys tools that perform better, last longer, and improve efficiency. To build a complete tool kit, you will need to purchase other tools separately, such as hammers, screwdrivers, and sockets. For a more comprehensive set, the Crescent 180-Piece Professional Tool Set offers a wider range of tools. However, for pliers specifically, the Channellock set is the ultimate choice for long-lasting quality and performance.
Five high-quality pliers in the Channellock set.
Craftsman 57-Piece Home Kit: Best Minimalist Set
The Craftsman 57-Piece Home Kit is a solid, compact tool set that provides a good balance of basic tools. For less demanding projects, this kit offers a practical selection of essentials. The fiberglass and rubber-handled hammer and slip joint pliers are among the better tools in this category, offering smooth action and comfortable grips. The screwdrivers are easy to use and effective. Instead of a magnetic bit driver, this kit includes a ratcheting screwdriver with a bit adapter, enhancing its versatility for various screws and bolts. The small socket set is conveniently sized and functional. Standard metric and SAE hex key sets are also included. The self-locking measuring tape with clear markings is a user-friendly feature.
While the sockets are not top-tier in quality compared to the Crescent set, they are adequate for general use. The snap-off knife is functional but less comfortable to hold. The plastic carrying case is acceptable, though sockets can easily fall out. For frequent socket use, the DeWalt 108-Piece Mechanics Tools Kit and Socket Set offers superior socket quality and case design. Nonetheless, the Craftsman kit delivers an excellent quality-to-value ratio, making it a great starter set for basic home projects or for those seeking quality tools on a budget.
Craftsman 57-Piece Home Kit tools including hammer and screwdrivers.
Black and Decker 20V Max 68-Piece: Good Value with a Drill Included
The Black and Decker 20V Max 68-Piece kit is a popular choice due to the inclusion of a cordless drill. For home repair projects involving screws, a cordless drill significantly reduces effort and time, making its inclusion in this set highly valuable. The drill comes with 10 drill bits, suitable for pilot holes for various screw sizes. Spade and hole saw bits are also included for larger hole drilling. The drill offers 11 torque settings for different applications. The pliers, needle nose pliers, and slip joint pliers are also decent quality in this set, offering a comfortable grip.
However, the drill is not designed for heavy-duty tasks. The battery provides about 25 minutes of continuous use, which may be limiting for larger projects, and requires over 3.5 hours to recharge. An extra battery purchase may be necessary for extended use. The carrying case is a simple tote bag without organizational pockets, which can lead to tools becoming disorganized. The hammer in this set is of lower quality, and the screwdrivers have unusually large bits. While the bit driver offers smaller bit options, the overall ergonomics of the pliers and snap-off blade could be better, and the adjustable wrench has noticeable wobble. Despite these shortcomings, this kit is a solid option for those needing a cordless drill for basic home tasks. For better hammer and overall tool quality, the Craftsman 57-Piece Home Kit is a worthwhile alternative.
Black and Decker cordless drill included in the tool kit.
Product Comparison
| Tool Set | Overall Score | Tool Quality & Function | Tool Selection for General Use | Carrying Case | Durability | Case Type | Uses |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crescent 180-Piece Professional Tool Set | 76 | 8.0 | 8.0 | 7.0 | 7.0 | Plastic hard case | General, cars, tractors, etc. |
| DeWalt 108-Piece Mechanics Tools Kit and Set | 74 | 9.0 | 5.0 | 8.0 | 8.0 | Plastic hard case | General, cars, tractors, etc. |
| Amazon Basics 173-Piece Hand Tool Kit | 67 | 6.0 | 9.0 | 6.0 | 5.0 | Plastic hard case | Basic household projects |
| Channellock 5-Piece Pliers Set | 67 | 9.0 | 2.0 | 7.0 | 10.0 | Soft roll case | Electric, plumbing, general |
| Craftsman 57-Piece Home Kit | 66 | 7.0 | 7.0 | 5.0 | 7.0 | Plastic case | Basic household projects |
| Black and Decker 20V Max 68-Piece | 64 | 5.0 | 9.0 | 6.0 | 5.0 | Soft tote bag | Household projects |
How Tool Sets Are Tested
Tool sets were rigorously tested head-to-head, compared against benchmark tools like a 40-year-old Stanley hammer and Channellock pliers of similar vintage. The testing process involved systematic evaluation of every tool in each set over several weeks. Hammers were used for driving and removing nails, pliers for wire work, wrenches and ratchets for bolts, and wire strippers for electrical tasks. Battery life and charging times were tested for cordless drills. Tool selection was assessed for overall utility and quality. Ratchets were used for ski binding adjustments, and wrenches for truck toppers and bicycle bolts. Finally, toolset costs were compared to assess value.
Testing was based on four key metrics:
- Tool Quality and Function (30% weighting): Assessing how well each tool performs its intended task.
- Tool Selection for General Use (25% weighting): Evaluating the versatility of the tool selection for common tasks.
- Carrying Case (25% weighting): Examining the case’s design, organization, and durability.
- Durability (20% weighting): Assessing the long-term robustness and expected lifespan of the tools.
Why Trust GearLab
Clark Tate, leading the tool testing team, has extensive experience from a farming background and vocational training, including building barns, roofing, Habitat for Humanity volunteering, and camper van construction. She advocates for high-quality tools that are durable and efficient. Clark involved her father, Glen Tate, to provide feedback from a larger user’s perspective.
Brian Smith, a professional mountain guide, carpenter of over 20 years, and bike mechanic for eight years, contributed his meticulous attention to detail and expertise in tool quality assessment. His experience in guiding people translates to helping consumers choose products that meet their needs.
Testing tool sets on a workbench.
Channellock pliers for larger jobs.
Analysis of Test Results
The toolset testing covered a wide range, from budget-friendly options for occasional use to professional-grade sets for daily tasks. Performance in each test metric is detailed below.
Best Value Tool Kits
Value is determined by balancing tool quality and functionality against cost. The Amazon Basics 173-Piece Hand Tool Kit is particularly noteworthy for its excellent tool selection for general home projects at a reasonable price. While some tools like pliers are less impressive, the kit is effective for many basic tasks.
AmazonBasics tool kit for basic household needs.
For a more refined selection of higher-quality basic tools, the Craftsman 57-Piece option is recommended. It offers fewer tools but with consistently good quality. For comprehensive DIY enthusiasts, the Crescent 180-Piece Professional Tool Set provides an extensive selection and high-quality tools at a fair value.
Investing in durable tools saves money over time. The Channellock 5-Piece Plier Set and the Crescent 180-Piece set are considered good long-term investments due to their high quality and durability.
Channellock tongue and groove pliers quality.
Tool Quality and Function Analysis
High-quality tools enhance efficiency and ease of use. Tool quality was a primary focus in testing. The Channellock Plier Set, DeWalt 108-Piece Mechanics Tools Kit and Socket Set, and Crescent 180-Piece Professional Tool Set kits ranked highest in tool quality, with Craftsman also offering solid functionality.
Channellock pliers, compared to a 40-year-old set, showed consistent quality and remained the sturdiest with superior action and grip. The needle-nose pliers are exceptionally precise, ideal for detailed wire work.
Testing ratchet quality with ski bindings.
The Crescent 180-Piece Professional Tool Set impressed with its sockets and combo wrenches, being the sturdiest and most comprehensive tested. The adjustable wrench had minimal play, maintaining its setting during use.
Crescent adjustable wrench quality.
The Craftsman 57-Piece Home Kit provides good value with functional basic tools. The socket set and hammer performed well.
The Amazon Basics and Black + Decker sets offer decent quality overall, though with some weaker tools. Amazon Basics pliers were subpar, and the Black + Decker hammer has a less durable design. However, the light, balanced hammer and mini socket set in the Amazon Basics kit are appreciated.
Black and Decker drill standing on its own.
The cordless drill in the Black + Decker 68-Piece kit is a significant advantage, saving time on tasks involving screws. It includes useful spade and hole saw bits. However, it is not powerful enough for heavy-duty tasks and has limited battery life.
Drill testing on metal and wood.
Lower-quality sets like the Dedeo Cordless Hammer Drill Kit and Cartman Orange 39-Piece are not recommended due to their subpar tool quality. The Cartman 148-Piece Set, Dekopro 158-Piece Tool Set, and Apollo Tools 71 Piece Household Kit are slightly better but still not as reliable as higher-rated kits.
Tool Selection for General Use Evaluation
While the Crescent and Channellock Pliers sets are high in quality, they lack basic household tools like hammers. The Crescent Professional Tool Set is more focused on automotive and engine-related tasks.
The Amazon Basics 173-Piece Hand Tool Kit offers the best tool combination for general household repairs, including a tape measure, nails, screws, and a torpedo level. A separate power drill is recommended for enhanced functionality.
The Craftsman 57-Piece Set is a well-rounded, pared-down option covering essential tools effectively. The Amazon Basics set offers similar functionality at a lower price but with inferior pliers.
Black and Decker drill clutch settings.
The Black + Decker 68-Piece kit is commendable for including a cordless drill along with basic hand tools, making it a good starter kit.
Dekopro wire strippers functionality.
The Dedo Cordless Hammer Drill Kit offers a wide selection but lacks quality. The Dekopro set has some pleasant basic tools but lacks overall quality in wrenches, sockets, and pliers.
Measuring tape included in most tool kits.
The Apollo Tools 71-Piece kit offers a unique selection for home repair and crafts, including a square, mini-hacksaw, rulers, and clamps, but most tools other than clamps and rulers are underperforming. The Cartman 148-Piece Set has usable screwdrivers and a hammer, but wrenches and sockets are subpar. The 39-Piece Cartman is very basic and lacks durability, particularly in the hammer.
Carrying Case Performance
Case quality varies significantly. The DeWalt case is superior, featuring metal buckles, secure tool holders, and excellent organization.
The Crescent plastic case effectively holds sockets and wrenches in place but may degrade over time due to plastic flexing. One test case had a minor defect.
Crescent case tool retention.
Cartman and Apollo cases are functional but made of lighter plastic, potentially less durable.
Apollo case tool organization.
Most plastic cases, like Craftsman, Dedeo, and Dekopro, have issues with tools falling out. Bag-style cases, like Amazon Basics, prevent tools from falling out but lack organization. The Black + Decker bag is basic, and the Channellock roll case is functional.
DeWalt case metal buckles and organization.
Durability Assessment
Durability is crucial for long-term value. Channellock pliers are built for longevity, though needle-nose pliers require careful use due to their fine tips.
40-year-old Channellock pliers vs new set.
Crescent wrenches, screwdrivers, and pliers are expected to be durable, with solid steel and rust-resistant chrome finish. Craftsman 57-Piece Home Kit tools are also expected to last.
Amazon kits are inexpensive, but pliers may not last long-term. Thin-necked hammers in Black + Decker, Apollo, and Cartman 39-Piece sets are less durable. Black + Decker tools are generally durable for moderate use. Dekopro Tool Set tools are serviceable but lower quality. Cartman 148-Piece Set has durable screwdrivers and a hammer. Dedeo kit tools are of low confidence regarding durability.
Drill battery life testing.
Choosing the Right Tool Set for Your Needs
Consider these factors when selecting a tool set:
Project Type
Determine the types of projects you will be undertaking. Are you focused on car maintenance, home repairs, or general DIY tasks? Choose a kit with tools relevant to your needs. Ensure it includes essentials like hammers, wrenches, screwdrivers, and a tape measure, and consider specialized tools based on your skill level and projects.
Tool set selection based on project needs.
Storage and Portability
Consider how you will store and transport your tools. If you need to move your toolkit frequently, choose a set with a durable and well-organized case. Evaluate the case’s ability to securely hold tools and withstand regular use.
Quantity vs. Quality
A large number of tools does not always equate to better value. Prioritize tool quality and select a set with tools made from high-grade materials and designed for durability. Focus on tools that are most useful for your specific requirements.
Tool Durability
Durability is a key factor for long-term cost savings and reliability. Look for tool sets with robust construction, such as strong joints in pliers and well-fitted sockets. Investing in durable tools ensures they will last and perform reliably when needed.
Investing in durable tool sets.
Conclusion
Selecting the right tool kit is a balance of tool quality, selection, and value. The ideal kit should handle common home and car repairs efficiently and reliably, minimizing trips to the store for missing tools. Prioritize quality over quantity for better performance and long-term value. Choosing durable, high-quality tools is an investment that reduces frustration and promotes sustainability.
